Hank Kalet, PopMatters.com,
February 7th 2004
Anarchy in the U.S.: Bob Dylan's Highway 61 Revisited
The year was 1965. America's involvement in Vietnam is escalating and
American troops are sent to the Dominican Republic in an attempt quell a
rebellion on the island.
The Johnson Administration announces an anti-poverty initiative as part of
his Great Society.
Selma, Alabama is racked with violence as segregationists attack peaceful
civil rights marchers and riots break out in Watts, causing 34 deaths and
injuries to 1,000 people.
Against this backdrop, Bob Dylan makes what will prove to be a prophetic
musical statement, plugging in, turning up the volume and altering the pop
music landscape for years to come.
First came Bringing It All Back Home, with one side of electric music and
one side of what can best be described as acoustic rock, followed in short
order by the single "Like a Rolling Stone", bursting onto the charts like
that first gunshot that started the Revolutionary War, and his
controversial electric performance Newport Folk Festival and the single.
And yet, all of that was just prelude. On August 30, Dylan released what
remains for me the most electrifying rock-and-roll album of all time,
Highway 61 Revisited. From its opening rim shot, which snaps the album
into motion, an opening that stands above nearly all others in the history
of rock and roll, a crack that strikes deep into the soul, Dylan spins and
whirls into a snarling, searing 51 minutes of anarchic imagery and music.
This is Bob Dylan at the height of his phantasmagoric powers, the dark
visionary, the painter of nightmarish inner landscapes who brings together
the strands of disparate worlds, mixes them and deconstructs them,
crafting a world of disillusion and alienation that offers what may have
been the first inclination that the Age of Aquarius was not all peace and
This is an album of brutality and innocence, an album that could only have
been produced by an artist at the height of his powers, with a war raging
overseas in the shadow of a presidential assassination. It is that rare
album on which not only are there no weak cuts, but on which each song is
a masterpiece, a classic rock and roll album.
Some history is in order, here. This is Dylan's second electric effort,
released in August of 1965, just five months after the remarkable Bringing
It All Back Home. The earlier effort featured an electric side and an
acoustic side, though the acoustic songs are nothing like anything he'd
recorded in the past. In structure, in approach, they are songs that seem
designed for full-band backing.
Dylan had been making the move toward rock and roll for about a year,
starting with the release of the more personal Another Side of Bob Dylan,
an album that lacked much of the topical fireworks of his two previous
albums. Another Side was still a folk album, but sounded different than
the folk music that was popular at the time both in terms of content and
Then in February 1965, Dylan released "Subterranean Homesick Blues", the
rollicking, rocking masterpiece that would forever change how rock and
roll would be played from then on. "Subterranean Homesick Blues", with its
images of revolution and chaos, prefigured the pitched political battles
that were to soon characterize the decade -- but its musical impact was
not apparent until the release in July of "Like a Rolling Stone" and
Dylan's fateful appearance at the Newport Folk Festival several days
The 1965 festival has taken on mythic stature in the annals of rock and
roll and there is some dispute over exactly what happened when Dylan
walked on stage dressed in leather jacket and white shirt with snap-tab
collar and cranked out his allegory of intellectual freedom, "Maggie's
Farm", "It Takes A Lot to Laugh" and "Like A Rolling Stone". There
apparently was booing and the crowd was angry -- though just how angry and
how much booing remains in dispute. He left the stage and came back to
play a pair of acoustic songs -- "It's All Over Now Baby Blue" and "Mr.
Tambourine Man" -- and left again.
He then went into the studio to record what was to become Highway 61
Revisited -- and it seems clear from the finished product, at least, that
Dylan was affected by what went down at Newport. Much of the album was
recorded and finished in the wake of Newport and some of the disc seems in
some ways a rebuke to those who had created an image of Dylan that Dylan
had no interest in living up to. (The brutal "Positively Fourth Street"
was recorded during these sessions, though not included on the album.)
Dylan had already made his statement of liberation on Bringing It All Back
Home, when he sang "Well, I try my best / To be just like I am / But
everybody wants you / To be just like them. / They sing while you slave
and I just get bored. / I ain't gonna work on Maggie's farm no more."
The result is Dylan's hardest rocking album, an album of biting satire and
vituperation, of fevered playing and controlled aggression.
There are the brutal recriminations of "Like a Rolling Stone", a song so
pointedly nasty, so harsh and unforgiving, that it is almost scary. "How
does it feel / How does it feel / To be on your own / With no direction
home / Like a complete unknown / Like a rolling stone?" Dylan sings,
running down the song's target, a woman who "dressed so fine" and attended
"the finest schools" only to find herself finally taken down a peg, lost
"Princess on the steeple and all the pretty people / They're drinkin',
thinkin' that they got it made / Exchanging all kinds of precious gifts
and things / But you'd better lift your diamond ring, you'd better pawn it
babe," Dylan sings without sympathy. "You used to be so amused / At
Napoleon in rags and the language that he used / Go to him now, he calls
you, you can't refuse / When you got nothing, you got nothing to lose /
You're invisible now, you got no secrets to conceal."
"Tombstone Blues" is a dervish of images and surging, gyrating music -- a
truly anarchic explosion of music. The key here is the mix -- somehow
producer Bob Johnston allows each of the players their own space, allows
us to hear each instrument as it weaves its musical line in and around the
others, with Michael Bloomfield's biting guitar and Al Kooper's rambling
piano charging up the entire effort.
"It Takes a Lot to Laugh, It Takes a Train to Cry" is Dylan's easy blues,
a hobo song that ambles along its way, the languid beat masking the
urgency -- hinted at throughout by Dylan's keening harmonica -- an urgency
that suddenly spills out in the final verse: "Don't say I never warned you
/ When your train gets lost." That hidden urgency explodes in Al Kooper's
bouncing organ on "From a Buick 6", as the singer navigates the cruelties
of the world, with a little help from his "soulful mama".
"Ballad of a Thin Man" reprises the theme of dislocation that Dylan raised
in "Like a Rolling Stone", telling the story of a man, Mr. Jones, lost in
the modern world, Mr. Jones wandering lost in the wilderness: "Because
something is happening here" but he doesn't "know what it is". But it also
is Dylan's response to the changing times, a coda to "The Times They Are
A-Changin'" in which he derides the comfortable and the would-be opinion
makers and trendsetters (He is "well read" and has "many contacts"). There
is the chuckle at the end of the first verse that lets you know Dylan has
no sympathy for Mr. Jones, the song tracing with a growing derision Mr.
Jones's pretensions and growing alienation -- "There ought to be a law /
Against you comin' around."
With "Queen Jane Approximately", Dylan leaves the door open, saying that
there might be some relief from the alienation and dislocation -- "Won't
you come see me, Queen Jane?"
Then comes the title cut, which kicks off what I've always thought of as a
three-song nightmare suite: "Highway 61 Revisited", "Just Like Tom Thumb's
Blues", and the majestic "Desolation Row". The songs pile up a series of
incongruous images, from the demanding god of Highway 61, where the good,
the bad, and the horrid are all quite at home, to the story of Tom Thumb
kicking around Juarez.
It is on "Desolation Row" that Dylan brings this nightmare to its logical
and illogical conclusion, with a host of unlikely characters --
Cinderella, Ezra Pound and T.S. Eliot, Dr. Filth and Nero -- casting about
in a world that seems to jump off a Brueghel canvas, or maybe out of a
William S. Burroughs novel. "They're selling postcards of the hanging /
They're painting the passports brown / The beauty parlor is filled with
sailors / The circus is in town," Dylan sings atop a truly beautiful
guitar line, a slowed-down flamenco riff that seems at odds with the
dislocation and brutality of the lyrics.
The lyrics are a thick jumble of images, much of them contradictory,
leaving us to wonder whether "Desolation Row" is heaven or hell. The Good
Samaritan is heading to the carnival, but Casanova is punished for going
there. Einstein had been famous "For playing the electric violin / On
Desolation Row", while Ophelia, who finds death "quite romantic", stares
at "Noah's great rainbow" and "She spends her time peeking / Into
And it's not as if the singer knows the answer either -- or that we are
asking the right questions: "All these people that you mention / Yes, I
know them, they're quite lame / I had to rearrange their faces / And give
them all another name / Right now I can't read too good / Don't send me no
more letters no / Not unless you mail them / From Desolation Row."
Highway 61 Revisited does not fit in comfortably with the other trends of
its time. It was one of a handful of albums (including the Beatles' Rubber
Soul and Revolver) that gave literate rockers the green light to create a
kind of intelligent, probing rock music that had not existed before.
But it also was, in many ways, the first punk-rock album -- it has the
same sense of antagonistic glee that the Sex Pistols brought to their
songs -- and hinted at the dissolution and discontent that would come only
a few years later, with the assassinations of Bobby Kennedy and Martin
Luther King Jr., with Altamont and the deaths of Janis Joplin, Jimi
Hendrix, Jim Morrison and others as the '60s turned to the '70s.
Bob Dylan, guitar, harmonica, piano and police car /
Michael Bloomfield, guitar / Alan Kooper, organ and piano / Paul Griffin,
piano and organ / Bobby Gregg, drums / Harvey Goldstein, bass / Charley
McCoy, guitar / Frank Owens, piano / Russ Savakus, bass. Produced by Bob